Monday, September 19, 2011

Hearing on LPG Storage Facility in Watkins Glen, NY


On Tuesday, September 27 the NY State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) is holding a public hearing on Inergy's application for a LNG storage and distribution facility on the shore of Seneca Lake, just three miles north of Watkins Glen.

The public hearing begins at 7pm in the Watkins Glen High School Auditorium, 301 12th St. Written comments accepted until Monday, October 10. Send your comments to:  David Bimber, Deputy Regional Permit Administrator, NYSDEC, 6274 East Avon-Lima Road, Avon, NY 14414-9516.

Inergy is a limited partnership developed to “acquire midstream energy assets.” They own and operate four natural gas storage facilities in NY and PA, with a combined gas storage capacity of 41 billion cubic feet (Bcf). Inergy also owns gas pipelines in NY and PA with 30 million cubic feet per day (MMcf/d) transportation capacity.

Their strategy, in their own words, is to “continue to develop a platform of interconnected natural gas assets that can be operated as an integrated Northeast storage and transportation hub”.

The Seneca Lake proposal

Inergy has proposed a new underground LPG storage facility for the storage and distribution of propane and butane on a portion of a 576 acre site located on NYS Routes 14 and 14A on the western shore of Seneca Lake. The storage facility will use existing caverns used by US Salt.

The company plans to store 2.10 million barrels (88.20 million gallons) of LPG in the salt caverns seasonally, displacing some of the brine currently filling them. The idea is to withdraw the fuel during the heating season.

During storage operations, the brine displaced by LPG will be stored and contained in a 14-acre double-lined surface impoundment with a capacity of 2.19 million barrels (91.98 million gallons) uphill of the facility.

The facility will connect to the existing TEPPCO LPG interstate pipeline, and will ship LPG by truck via NYS Routes 14/14A and rail via the existing Norfolk & Southern Railroad. The proposed project involves construction of a new rail and truck LPG transfer facility, consisting of a 6 rail siding capable of allowing loading/unloading of 24 rail cars within 12 hours, and a truck loading station capable of loading 4 trucks per hour.

Public concerns:
  • Residents are concerned about the large 14-acre brine pit.
  • They are concerned about the increased rail and truck traffic in a tourist area.
  • They are concerned about safety – and note that Inergy has refused to release details of their planned safety measures until after the permit is granted. One concern is the proximity to Watkins Glen.
  • They are concerned about air quality issues from the increased truck traffic and potential impacts of ground level ozone and other pollutants on wine grapes and other agricultural crops.
  • They are concerned about the impact of this industrialization on the tourism and wine industry.
  • They are concerned about the integrity of the brine pit in terms of “extraordinary” weather.
  • They would like Inergy and DEC to disclose the number of years of similarly-sized LNG storage facilities and the number of accidents and explosions, so that an honest evaluation can be made of the possible disaster.
You can read the Environmental Impact Statement for the project at http://www.dec.ny.gov/permits/71619.html. Check out what my colleague, journalist Peter Mantius has to say about the project here.

Thursday, September 15, 2011

EPA Hearings: Air Pollution Standards for Oil and Gas Production

The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) will hold three public hearings in September on the agency’s proposed standards to reduce air pollution from oil and gas drilling operations.  The proposed standards would rely on cost-effective, existing technologies and practices to reduce pollution that contributes to smog and can cause cancer, while supporting the administration’s priority of continuing to expand safe and responsible domestic oil and natural gas production.  The first hearing will be held in Pittsburgh on September 27. The other hearings will be in Denver, Colorado and Arlington, Texas.  

Pittsburgh Hearing: 9 am - 8 pm, Tuesday, Sept. 27
David L. Lawrence Convention Center, Rooms 315-316
1000 Ft. Duquesne Blvd.
Pittsburgh, PA 15222

Denver Hearing: 9 am-8 pm, Wed. Sept. 28
Colorado Convention Center, Room 207
700 14th Street
Denver, Colorado 80202

Arlington Hearing: 9 am - 8 pm, Sept. 29
Arlington Municipal Building in the City Council Chambers
101 W. Abram Street
Arlington, Texas 76010

To register to speak at a specific time at any of the hearings, please contact Joan C. Rogers at 919-541-4487 or rogers.joanc@epa.gov. People also may sign up to speak in person on the day of a hearing; however, they may not be given their preferred time slot to speak.

Public comments will be accepted through October 24, 2011. When you submit your comments, identify them by Docket ID number EPA-HQ-OAR-2010-0505.

Ways to submit written comments:
  • online at the Federal rulemaking portal -  www.regulations.gov
  • by email to A-and-R-Docket@epamail.epa.gov
  • by FAX at 202-566-9744
  • by postal service (include 2 copies) to: Docket ID number EPA-HQ-OAR-2010-0505, 1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Washington, DC 20460
If you mail comments, please mail an additional copy to: The Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, OMB, Attn.: Desk Officer for EPA, 725 17th St. NW, Washington, DC  20503

EPA must issue a final rule by Feb. 28, 2012. More information at http://epa.gov/airquality/oilandgas/

You can read the 106-page announcement of the rules in the Federal Registry at

For further information contact Bruce Moore at 919-541-5460 or by email at moore.bruce@epa.gov

Saturday, August 27, 2011

NY Hydrofracking Rules Scheduled for Release Wed. Aug 31

Time to sharpen your pencils and get your thinking caps on. According to press reports the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation will finally release the SGEIS (Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement) for high-volume horizontal hydraulic fracturing on Wednesday, the very last day of August. That 1,000+ page document should include all the sections that were labeled "to come" in the previously released (July 8) version. It should include socio-economic data but also some environmental information that was lacking from last month's draft.

Wednesday will also be the day residents learn exactly how long the comment period will be and whether the DEC will hold any public hearings. According to press reports, Governor Cuomo thinks 60 days is plenty long to read and respond to a 1100 or so page document.

Check DEC's website for the latest info, postings or versions of the SGEIS.



Wednesday, August 24, 2011

Marcellus Math: Fun with Frack-tions

It’s official: the Marcellus shale formation, stretching beneath the northern Appalachians, contains about 84 trillion cubic feet of gas – at least that’s what the US Geological Survey said this Tuesday. This is way higher than the figure they published nine years ago- some 42-times higher. Back in 2002 USGS calculated that Marcellus contained about 1.9 tcf of gas.

At the same time, the 84 tcf figure is way lower – some 326 trillion cubic feet lower – than the estimate published by the US Energy Information Agency on July 8, only six short weeks ago. Back then the Energy Department posited that Marcellus shale contained 410.3 tcf.

But yesterday said Philip Budzik, an operations research analyst with the Energy Information Administration, allowed that the folks at USGS are the experts in this matter. “They’re geologists; we’re not,” he said. From here on out, he promised, EIA will use the updated USGS estimate in their models and calculations.

So how did this number get so inflated? It all started back in 2009 when Penn State University geoscience professor Terry Engelder and a Fredonia, NY geology professor by the name of Gary Lash took some well production data and plugged it into a formula. Eureka! they gasped, looking at the numbers they generated. Those numbers indicated that the Marcellus shale could contain anywhere from 168 trillion to 516 trillion cubic feet of gas. That’s a lot of gas – about 80 to 250 times the government estimate.

Engelder’s magic number zipped around the world before the research could catch up. Pro-industry apologists used it to prove claims of potential energy security and secure leases. The NY DEC pasted it into theirMarcellus information pages. “Geologists estimate that the entire Marcellus Shale formation contains between 168 trillion to 516 trillion cubic feet of natural gas throughout its entire extent,” DEC wrote. But, they cautioned, “it is not yet known how much gas will be commercially recoverable from the Marcellus in New York.”

Pennsylvania’s Dept. of Conservation and Natural Resources had the higher estimate posted on their website as well. They added another report, a study co-authored by Kuuskraa and Stevens that estimates Marcellus shale gas recoverable reserves at 100 to 200 Tcf.

Industry PR folks didn’t let the fact that the revised USGS figure is 1/5 of the number they’ve been touting – they simply ignored that inconvenient fact and highlighted the increase over the previous USGS number.

On late Wednesday the Congressman from New York, Maurice Hinchey told the press that back in June he had sent a letter to the US Energy Information Agency questioning its shale gas reserve estimates. “And for good reason,” he said, referring to the USGS Marcellus downgrade.

Though Hinchey applauds the EIA for announcing it will adopt the USGS estimates, he remains  concerned about the process which lead to the original estimates.

“I have additional questions about how this change will impact the outlook for shale gas,” he said. “Considering the reckless way in which hydraulic fracturing has been carried out in other parts of the country, it is important that we understand all of the environmental and economic impacts that would result if drilling were to move forward in our state. That's why it is essential that the public, the markets and policy makers have unbiased shale gas reserve estimates.”

Numbers are important – especially for decision-makers involved in determining our country’s energy future, Hinchey said. “We’ve got to get this right.”

Saturday, August 20, 2011

Fracking the Tar Sands

Alberta, Canada is gorgeous - boreal forest, helicopter skiing in winter for those who can afford it, land of glaciers that provide source water for many ... and the Tar Sands.

Tar Sands contain hydrocarbons (which is how they got their name). They are, like Marcellus and other shales, an "unconventional" source for fossil fuels - and their industrialized extraction is on par with mountaintop removal. Even the industry admits the land will never be recovered.

Josh Fox recently produced a short video for a "Stop the Tar Sands" campaign  that shows what mining Tar Sands in Alberta looks like. It does not matter whether you are pro-gas or not, you should know where your energy comes from.

I'm not advocating that you drive to DC to protest.
I'm not advocating that you sign a gas lease.

But if we are determined to continue our dependence on fossil fuels, we must understand where our  energy comes from.




Tar Sands Action/ Josh Fox from JFOX on Vimeo.