What happens when gas drilling and organic agriculture
collide? This series considers some of the issues. Posts are drawn from a
3-part series originally published in New York Organic News (NOFA-NY) in 2012.
Research was supported with a grant from SEJ's Fund for Environmental Journalism.
When Carol French signed a gas lease she never dreamed that
half a dozen years later she’d be warning other farmers to think twice. French,
a dairy farmer in Bradford County, Pennsylvania, lives in the midst of the
drill zone. The last time she counted, there were nine active wells located
within a mile of her farm.
![]() |
| photo by Frank Finan |
Carolyn Knapp, an organic dairy farmer, lives just a couple
miles away. Six years ago she was concerned that signing a lease might affect
her organic status. It didn’t. Now, with a handful of wells drilled nearby, she
worries about other ways that gas drilling and exploration could impact her
operation.
The problem: gas leases do not protect farmland. Once those
leases are signed, say Knapp and French, farmers lose control over their land.
Gas companies decide where to place access roads, well pads, pipelines and
compressors – and that can interrupt normal farming activities.
One of French’s neighbors ended up with a well pad sited
behind his barn, effectively cutting off easy access to the fields and pasture.
The farmer is earning royalties, French said – about $400/month. But he sold
his cows because the drilling operations made it too hard to keep on farming.
Knapp, who integrates intensive grazing into her dairy operation, said drillers
planned to dig a 20-acre water impoundment right in the middle of her
rotational grazing system.
Agricultural land is hit particularly hard; research shows
that in the Marcellus, farmland makes up about 62 percent of the acreage
affected by drilling. And when Penn State professor Tim Kelsey surveyed Bradford
and Tioga counties in PA, his data showed that the number of wells in an area
has an impact on farming. Areas with 150 or more gas wells lost 19 percent of
their dairy herd; areas with no wells experienced only a 1 percent loss.
He doesn’t have an exact number, but Kelsey says there is no
doubt that dairy farmers are quitting because of drilling. Even if their own
farms are not impacted, farmers face other challenges. Landowners who used to
lease fields to farmers are now renting their land for drilling-related uses
such as equipment storage and water withdrawal sites. Large impoundments take
land out of production, and crop yields are down in reclaimed pipeline
right-of-ways. Add to that the scarcity of sawdust for bedding (it’s mixed with
drill cuttings before they’re trucked to landfills) and the recent addition of
an 8-cent-per- hundredweight surcharge for hauling milk (gas companies pay higher
wages for those with CDL licenses) and it’s clear that the Marcellus boom is a
bust for some farmers.

